<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<item xmlns="http://omeka.org/schemas/omeka-xml/v5" itemId="6728" public="1" featured="0" xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance" xsi:schemaLocation="http://omeka.org/schemas/omeka-xml/v5 http://omeka.org/schemas/omeka-xml/v5/omeka-xml-5-0.xsd" uri="http://exhibits.library.stonybrook.edu/mfp/items/show/6728?output=omeka-xml" accessDate="2026-06-07T13:01:30+00:00">
  <fileContainer>
    <file fileId="3784">
      <src>http://exhibits.library.stonybrook.edu/mfp/files/original/c825cf38265f35eaf923d1fdede27f5a.pdf</src>
      <authentication>8e37b7104043290b0428aed652df73e2</authentication>
      <elementSetContainer>
        <elementSet elementSetId="4">
          <name>PDF Text</name>
          <description/>
          <elementContainer>
            <element elementId="52">
              <name>Text</name>
              <description/>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="104410">
                  <text>Manhasseit Medical Center Hospital
4CZ54@/¢/;ﬁé€rn.2%éui%§C}¢%;lﬂéd536/ c&lt;lgeyi

N ]E W Y O R K

PEARL A.KLICK
ADMINISTRATOR

35K

TELEPHONE

MANHASSET

7-4000

1:

"VINE

February 25, 1957
Dear Doctor:

Quarterly Medical Staff Meeting of the Manhasset Medical Center
Hospital will be held on Thursday, March 7, 1957, at 8:h5 P.M.,
promptly at THE ALLISON, 1583 Northern Boulevard, almost directly
opposite the hospital.

The

PART

faRT

1. Review and analysis of Clinical werk in the Surgical and
Medical Sections for the month of December 1956, and the
months of January, February 1957 inclusive.

2.

A.

Surgical Section - Ralph S. Emerson, M.D., Chairman

B.

Medical Section

-

3

‘§~
“

Lawrence S. Kryle, M.D., Chairman

Tissue Committee Report - Howard L. walker, M.D., Chairman

SCIENTIFIC

PROGRAM

-

Arnold G. Blumberg, M.D., Chairman

"THE TRANQUILIZERS IN PSYCHIATRIC PRACTICE
AND THEIR APPLICATION TO GENERAL PRACTICE."

Dr. Maximilian Fink
Director of Research in Experimental Psychiatry
Hillside Hospital, Glen Oaks, N. Y.
COLLNTION.

Respectfully yours,
John G. Connell, M.D.
President - Medical Board

Telephone number

The
MA 0

Allison is
7"558’4v

at

Harry H. Abrahams, M.D.
Secretary - Medical Board

~ﬁg

��mmmwm,wmpmmmmmmmm
at then obs-mum, w an
both» that

m.
WW
WMMwnwmmoma-pmiwhcwnmmw
Mx

«811.1%

unit-(unmask

mmmumtmwumatmimummmmm

”demhmlm,wmm
mummmmmmmaMaummmmwm
m
Intact.
WWWuloatmthm.
and

Minimum new

'4»

obmﬂw,

We!» afresh.

mmm»mwmmmt¢mhumo£mpmuyotmwb
mm and than mm). mm. m: max-minim at than m mt:
dWarinwclm,thntwhu-Wtomuswwmﬂd~
mwhmmmpemﬂmwhopawnmmwhmmml
behavior me:- that special

mum d um

brain {motion (we Seats.“ 6).

WWanhnwhduwmamtatolmkawm

mmwammmmmmmmmtdmzmmntmt.
shock a a manic mutant. Salaam” mug" in mm Maﬁa which

metro-v

mm

two
than
than
of
lengthlarva-yang
many
him,
mm.
persist
than
Mending
in
way:
his
to
almond!
wfamt
patent
mums

mmaponomiw.
M13,

am
whammpomnmummmmwm

his therapist, an! to other mum“.

mthrMha

when

M

oﬁurmple,musammutMnforhintoMo-nm,mmw
in
tutu
mum.
it
mam, mum tulinaorwnhomisut

by

an

mth

bother

muty

to

Man

with othon.

ma
£106th thaw

“Mammummtfortwmtmotwmma
'

_

studio: at

Mama.

m not“

mt

«that

:Inth-ooumurthau

32:”:me

had

am

that

mmwnwumummnmmmnmmrm,w

��«In

WW‘

AathtMpnviam momm
W338 in the mm at inﬂiﬂéml MW in «mm. Mﬂty Ml
.

ummmwmummekam. wmamuamum
mammnmammlma. nmlamamwuu

W

dummiom W

whom.
manummuumuhmormmmmuméapmrmwm
mt: or

or

induced by

mammm: Wmhhymmlﬁuut marmmmw,wuw
Wmuhtiam the,

response to

tin

«mm mama to 3551mm m boa

umwwmmummmm(mmm Win
In, itumuipum
thutmlmntarywmmmmsumhm

mmmuutnnmmmMmpmummum,mmtm

”munm'mummmw.
Gum
the
the
alumna-hip
mm «Mmmad
anmmmmamlmmummmnmwmw
mat of 01
tramway. we may in mum."
concurrently, Dr.

~

--

has

-

w

na-

3.

am, hu

mm

and ten

W
3.“

4

aw, under as:

013an

have

a: Dr. 31am mmbut: museum hero-m tho In

Mmmmmmmmm manmummmmmu

ammmchunamammmma‘nmsmwmawmm

chum.

'

4* m:
mmwmxmmmmmmmmmuor
.

,

magma...

mmnwmmuwummmmamwm
maxim/:31“.
hmm,‘§9‘pﬁmunhmdtwmmmm
1957.

ﬂammmmnmwmmmmwmmw
«Mammal!»
It
cmluim
”was

M.

«human
”mom” ﬂammable Warpatumulmmmtham.
mm

that.

as

�.5.

mm m

be
the
for
diseharge
to
better for the claim-pren—
ratings
team
uino group than for tho
um group. H. emclmd that, in
to 111M131: new therapy, ehloxpmine m mar, easier to
aura
contmlhbla in its effects. and had fmr $5.60 attach. We 3190 amended
tint n9 evidame had appear“ in the fiftm math: a! the study that. either
than” had altered thy basic. schiaaphmie process, nor did my real that either
tom of therapy had a greater speciﬁcity far schizophnnie illnesses. At the
concluaim of the stndy, the ladies). Biroctur placed
in tin for»

ulary and

a

um

13¢th
a.

its use

13m

IV

smut:

mm”,

the maidont staff.

W:

@10me

During this” period Dr. Green has

evaluﬂd

magma, for its ability to bring out
debuts in brain mum. The "port. at his findings mm meant-ad at. the
aid-winter muting of the Eutem lasaeiation of Bleetroancephalographam.
dials :6. Pro «aka
8:
It. is anticipated that tha mark now in prams: in we
will continue for the remainder of the year. The aleetmshock evaluation
study will be cmletod this spring and the next few months will ha spent in
a new agent in ulcetrooncepmlographg,

M

'

«muting

biannual: chained and writing the reports. As indicated
in the ongoing pmgraaa not”, a. War of development: have grown out. at these
studies and it. is anticipated that than will he immoramd in the mum n—
the

W

aeamh pmgrlm

1.
been

«aloud by

Diffomma 3.3; Wen}. Romam
pmtocol has
Dr. “a: Franck, which incorporates than pmblem or panama
11

dictating individual rosponsivity to abattoshoek. By entertaining than
subject‘ 8 patterns of perception in awfully devolopod arianhatim and visual

1uy

tasks, in hope to demonstrate

O.

“hump

batman: those pater-nu and the

bov-

both
havioral
under the. special conditim of altered brain funcuun.
and the general condition of hospitalisation and plywothompy. 8min a study

ream,

has bearing on tha problems of the personality

upset: of resume to

change

�«6.

in behavior wider stressful maniacs (us in forceful indactrimum, isolatim.
atarmtim); a3 well as an «imam at mimic madame fer various W“

chntric therapies.

ma
mamwwwm
me
mums“
W
w:
2.

with elootmahock have led us to

Em-

theua

mute personality factors in the patient and

which

ing the chain of treatment.
a workabla hypothasia.

We

He

of

a.

hypo—

the tharapi‘at affect»

am in the process of developing our ideas into

antiéipate mdertnking such

Mt

I

stuck by the and of the

last report this section has been mdeaigna‘bed an the
of Men-1mm thiatry. In addition to the panama]. listed

31am the
Department

the

timofﬂwwtmport,mhmappointad, maparttimbasis,

mm

at.

mm

assistant in psychalngy. Dr. Pomek, who has his 111.11.
from Kw York: University in 1955, has bean a mum-oh psychologist at tho Haunt
Sinai Hospital and the 145mm rmdaum for emu Research for the past six
Ha
is experienced in both pamanauty and perceptual ”pants in march.
years.
It. in anticipatod that he will be appoint“ an 2. m1 tin basis on My 131:.
A
the
individual
differences in bahavior with specific ambush
to
study
pram
Pamela, as

on tho

perceptual and

ation has been

made

pemmnty sweats

has teen

«“10de by his and applic-

to various foundations for support.

mauve April 131:, than

will be appeintod to the

Duparfanent, a

Assistant for linguistic analyses. Under the hem of the
E) funds warn and:

mm“
x.

devised ‘by

m:
21::

«:1th

Firm.”

far a technical assistant he carry
Dr. Jane.

manna»!

1mm

Grant (see
out.

Senna

the language

for Renaud: in Psyuhutry has gxmtad Dr. Jute
sun or [26,919 plml $5,700 overhud far continuum

Fund

support for two years in than
of the study “Language of the

Dyna“ which

has been dmlopod during hm past year.

�ﬂan

MMMMmWVWWrmum. mama-mm
«mumspm

1st.

3957

unmmmt.

1959.

mmmmmummmmuwudmmwm

mararmmawmmmwmam £100»,me

mumwmmmxmm-mwmmwmzwnmm
ammwmnmmummmsumw,wmmmm

InWr,;mawrthammkqu

atmmwmammmmmtmummm

mummuuwnhumamunumsmmumwwm

nmr,nr.ammmmnm
mmmmw.
inmwmmmmmwhgmwnwnmemum

mm‘dWomx-l. kWawﬂmWﬁs
dWWWWMMmmmmmammm
in
m Widv mom 153mm my.
autism
“MW
tho

Em

MWMWtWamrdmmawvmmmuMmr
ﬂammmrmmu»hpoumha1umtorpnmumu
an Week mum}: mama. th- smosy or Mom-1 WW, tho

Inumhiml Wan

of

RM

and the Imam-Mom}.

0mm! fer WW.‘

hmumnmmmmwwwumwunmmm
ma
for
humﬁml
Puma? ”W4.
Mm:
WM: mum

mummnnmmmmmammwnam
thrmthMme,uthw-omcmmmmm
summeodmga.
Womanhmmmmmwupummmma

mmwwm.hﬂo,umupmmungmormm

mum»“momwmdummotmmrdmwmmmm
Chum;

�vammamwmmmmmmamw
fowlmm. unnaommmwanmnmmum
or
J. Mt. 1:
in

Manny
mm}.
m
3mm
mm:

Dr.
anti-u”.
main
mum” at. an mum Alma: mu mum

means

with

an

W
Wthmmuthortmmmmho-

W,
matmwmmmmumum.

of

Dr.

a

mmmamnmsmvm‘mmmm

Morn a: thin-Baum: an «an in an «Mama and m...

other 19%.

numtatmthm;

WW:
mwmmwmm. DnlgmmbmnmngtMpmbhmof

smwwmmmmuhmm

0

Wm
wmwammmw‘mﬂammwhmmm.
mm
puma
pm:
mm
mm
is
um We
Wm
mmuwappmuwmmumm. hummmpmaaar
with

acumen ”mm.

Elam

during

typu of

no

bu been mpcmm

ﬂu «mm-hock
maniacal... 69min supports.“ an!

that.

and

In thin new: be

mmmwumum.
Dr. 3.

Fri-mm contributed mun-My to mmamm mm.

mmmmmmwwmw.

In

WWmnodWMme,mmofmmmtmm

mm

m a may

mm“ mm:

m- m

on
at
.m
u»
mam
mm:

mmmmmmmuw.
Manama,

WM”
W

1913!!

a: tum-3mm

Mammary:

Wm

Max

Pink.

11.13.

�March 1957

Personality Factors in Behavioral Beeponse to Electroshock Therapy
Robert L. Kahn, Ph. D. andMax Pink,

From
New

14.

D.

the Department of Experimental Psychiatry, Hillside Hospital, Glen Oaks,

York.

Aided by grant 14-927 of the National Institute of Mental Health, l“aﬁcional Institutes of Health, APublic Health Service.

Presented

a

the Electroshock Research Association, Chicago,

May

1957.

�INTRODUCTION

The

behavioral response of patients receiving electroshock therapy is

variable. In previous studies of the factors related to this variability

we

that patients who showed early, persistent and relatively marked degrees
of altered brain function, as measured by the e1ectroencephalogram.and the
amobarbital test for brain disease (10), were most likely to show a clinical
The
(h)
(6)
which
(7).
improved
rated
was
present study is an
as
response
investigation of the role of personality in the behavioral reSponse.
An explicit hypothesis concerning this relationship has been derived

noted

from previous studies of the patterns of behavioral change occurring with
EST.

In an analysis of language changes after electroshock (7),

that patients

who

we

reported

develop such language patterns as explicit denial of

ill-

and
of
and
symptoms;
displacement
qualifitemporal
Spatial
personal,
ness;
cation, evasion and minimization are rated as improved. These language patterns

are similar to those previously described by Weinstein and

Kahn (13)

in their

studies of neurological patients with cerebral dysfunction. They characteru
ized this behavior as the "language of denial" and demonstrated a relationship

to personality. In particular they described the characteristics of the "ex€M)On
the
of
these
the
denial"
basis
verbal
observations,
personalit
plicit
hypothesis was advanced that those patients

who most

closely approximated this

"explicit verbal denial" personality type would be more likely to
havioral changes after
The purpose

EST

show

the be-

which are rated as improved.

of the present study, therefore, was to determine:

1) whether personality characteristics related to the behavioral
reaponse

to electroshock therapy

show

proved.

differentiated; and

patients with greater "denial" tendencies are more likely
behavioral changes after electroshock therapy which are rated as imp
2) whether

to

can be

�.2POPULATION

Sixty-three consecutive patients referred for electroshock therapy were
studied.

staff,

The

selection of patients for treatment

was made by the

psychiatric

independent of the judgment of the authors. The patients ranged in age

from 20

to

66 with a mean of I47, and included 21 men and

142

women.

METHOD

Prior to treatment each patient

was evaluated according

to the following

methods :

l.

Structured

EM

Interviews: Personality was evaluated in inter-

patient' 3 family. At the opening of the interview,
the relative was asked to describe, in his own words, the patient's usual interests and attitudes. The relatives were encouraged to talk about any aspect
they wished, and the interviewer followed the trend of their talk, rather thm
proceeding in a serial fashion. The interviewer asked questions, however, to
been
15
obtain information in m
described as charspecific areas which have

views with members of the

acteristic of the "explicit verbal denial" personality,“.

The number and

withgibrelative
varied according to the degree of
type of questions required
spontaneous production and the infomant' 3 capacity to comprehend and 00mm:-

icate.

The

informant was encouraged to give concrete examples of

all state-

ments.

basic items included the presence and extent of each of the following
features: 1) stress verbal symbols such as resolutions, homilies, cliches and
The

rationalization; 2) are prestige and security conscious, and do not enjoy the
intrinsic benefits of health, work, leisure, money and property; 3) regard illness as an imperfection or disgrace, keeping

neighbors, and are

it

a secret from the family and

reluctant to seek medical care;

troubles and are considered practical persons

who

)4)

"shake off"

their

advise others; 5) have

drive and compulsive energr, and are guilty or uneasy

if

own

much

not occupied; 6) are

conscientious with a high sense of duty and responsibility; 7) are sensitive
.

�.3to criticism, regarding

it as

an

attack

on

their integrity;

8)

are proud and

avoid help from others; 9) are reserved rather than openly affectionate or
emotional; 10) emphasize being correct; 11) are not imaginative or creative;
12) are not seen as dependent by

their relatives;

1h) do not have temper outbursts; 15) and are not

After the interview, each item

if

score of 0 was given
1
2

was

rated

on a

13) do not discuss sex openly;

ludic (25).
scale of 0, 1 or 2.

A

the aSpect was noted to a minimal degree; a score of

indicated that the characteristic was moderately present; while a score of
indicated the definite and marked presence of the pattern. The scores for

each item were added and the

resultant score is termed the "denial personality

score".

2. Clinical Evaluation: Each patient
weekly intervals during and

evaluation

prior to and at
following the course of treatment. The clinical

was determined by

was interviewed

the patient's behavior in the few weeks following

the end of the course of treatment and

was

based on the evaluation of the pat-

ient's therapist, the therapist's supervising psychiatrist and the supervising
psychiatrist in charge of the electroshock treatment unit. Patients were
classed into three groups:

much improved,

moderately improved, or unimproved,

criteria outlined previously (6).
3. Language gtggy: In addition to the clinical interviews,

following the

each patient

standardized series of questions determining his attitude

was examined with a

toward his

illness.
trouble?" and "If you

Two

of the questions asked were,

“What

is

youi'mein

had one wish, what would you wish for?" The

patients

were

tested before and during treatment and the verbatim responses were analyzed for
changes in language according to the method previously described (7).
RESULTS

The

relatives of

scores ranged from

O

h?

patients were interviewed. The&lt;ienia1 personality

to 25, with a median of 11. For statistical comparison

�.14-

the patients were divided into two groups. Patients with scores ranging from
11
0

to
to

25 were

10 were

frm

considered the "high denial" group, while those with scores

classed as low in denial tendencies.

1. Personality score and clinical response: Patients with high denial
personality scores in these family interviews were most likely to be rated as
much improved, and

patients with

low scores, however, the

basis, with

chance

only one case was considered unimproved (Table

30%

I).

In

clinical response rating occurred

on a

of the patients being regarded as mimproved.

I

TABLE

Relation of Denial Personality Scores to Clinical Response to Electroshock
Much

Improved

Moderately
Improved

Total

Unimproved

Personality Score
11
0

-

25

1h

9

1

2h

10

7

9

7

23

21

18

8

it?

Total
The

proved

difference in the denial scores between the

patients,

when compared

sigzificant.* Although the

much and

moderately im-

to the unimproved patients is statistically

much improved

patients have a higher

mean

score

is not significant.
2. Qualitative observations: Although there is a relationship between
high denial personality scores and the clinical rating, 30% of patients with
than the moderately improved group, this difference

low denial scores were also evaluated as showing a marked improvement. While
trig/1:119 group

of seven patients

is

a small one , certain

common

characteristics can

be described. Although these subjects lack the competitive

security needs of the high denial subjects, they
or imaginative capacity or ability to think
Si
~K-

vb; { {ran-M

at

1%

level of confidence by

show

drive, prestige and
a similar lack of creative

critically of their

Mann-Whitney

U

Test.

own

or other's

�.5relate to the environment primarily by non-verbal forms of
commmication. They are described by their families as laughing or crying

feelings.

They

excessively; and as showing anger by muteness, ”go into a shell," ”walk out

of the room in a huff,” or by violent tempers with table-pounding, throwing
objects or direct physical assault. These patients are "ludic,"
by Weinstein and Kahn (12) to denote comic,

language analysis described in a

in clinical interviews

term used

tragic, or melodramatic behavior.*

1m:
previous study (7), the

3. Personality score and Meg

-a

Applying the technic of

i__n_

changes

in

language

were compared with the denial personality scores. Nine

patterns of language change, such as explicit denial of illness or

symptoms,

displacement, qualification, £33. have been described as characteristically

occurring

after electroshock.

ified according to the

plicit language

As

in the previous study, each patient

was

class-

dichotomy of whether or not he showed three or more ex-

changes. Patients with high denial personality scores showed

a greater number of language changes, than those with low denial personality

scores (Table

II).

The

coefficient of correlation between the personality

scores and the number of language changes

the

1%

is

.71, significant

+

at better than

level of confidence.
TABLE

II

Relation of Denial Personality Scores to Clinical Language Changes During
Treatment
Number Langggge Changes

0

-

2

3

or

more

Personality Scores
11 .- 25

(20)

8

12

-

(20)

17

3

25

15

o

10

Total
This term was taken from Piaget who applied
behavior of young children (8).

*-

it to

the play and imitative

�h. Illustrative Cases:
Case

1. High Denial Personality Score:
A

61-yearbold housewife was admitted to the hospital with a 15

history of insomnia, abdominal pain and fear of cancer. On admission
she was depressed, retarded, and seclusive, evincing little interest in her

month

surroundings, and wandering aimlessly about the ward.
The

patient

reaponsible person with
and was unable
home.

her husband as a conscientious, dependable,
integrity. She had no hobbies, outside interests,

was described by
much

to relax.

She was ”mortally

As

a consequence, she busied herself with chores

at

afraid" of doctors, minimized her illnesses and con-

cealed ailments, even from her husband. Very restrained, she openly showed no

affection or emotion, never discussed sex and rarely lost her temper. She had
"a long memory for little things if she felt that she was wronged," a ”streak
of stubborness," and would "just as soon hold another person responsible for

her mistakes." She was proud and would ”rather go without food" than borrow
or take money from others.
According to the denial

criteria, her score

After 20 electroshock treatments, she

was 20.

became euphoric, took an

interest

in her personal appearance and participated in hospital activities. Her doc"model"
”while
her
who,
a
reluctant to discuss her personal
patient
toi/called
feelings, asserted that she had no difficulties at

hue-'had
home,
a wonderful

band.uho was very good to her, considered herself lucky and eagerly anticipated

her discharge.”
Case

She was discharged with a

2.
A

Low

rating of

"much improved."

Denial Personality Score:

hl-year-old housewife

was admitted

to the hospital with a two

year history of depression following the birth of her fourth child. She cried

frequently, lost interest in social activities, found it increasingly difficult
to take care of her baby and had suicidal thoughts. On admission the patient

�was'

noted to pay

little attention

showed psychomotor

The
whom
He

it

patient

retardation

and was

was described by

was not easy

to her personal appearance, cried readily,
circumstantial in speech.

her husband as a "negative personality” with

to get along because she

was opinionated and argumentative.

regarded her as "completely impractical, with no

common

sense." She was a

poor housekeeper, constantly demanding help from other people, although not the
kind of person who would put herself out for others.

An

excessively talkative

person, she liked to engage in long, intellectual, pretentious conversations.
When

angry, however, she would become either completely mute, or "very nasty,

just don't know any better.” Although considered a “cold" person,
able to talk freely about sex. She frequently complained of physical

implying you
she was

ailments and went to physicians readily. She was ”naive" and "unrealistic,"

believing, for example, that she had a

flair for writing

although others con-

sidered her amateurish.
Her

personality score

was

rated as h.

patient received eighteen electroshock treatments, which were terminated at her own insistence because she was too frightened to take any more.
At the time of her discharge her doctor noted her as "quite depressed,” but
The

felt that
hospital.

it

was

doubtful that she could benefit from further treatment

She was discharged with

at

the

the recommendation for continued psychother-

apy.
DISCUSSION

The

structured family interview

was designed

to test the specific hypo-

thesis derived from earlier observations that patients with the "explicit
verbal denial” personality are most likely to Show both the language and behavioral changes to electroshock therapy which are rated as
the examiner.

The

much improved by

data supports this hypothesis and is also consistent with

�the theory of the

mode

of action of electroshock therapy advanced by Weinstein,

that “....the therapeutic efficacy of
electroconvulsive therapy....derives from the production of a state of brain
function in which the mechanism of denial is facilitated in characterologically

Linn and Kahn in 1952 (9).

They suggest

diaposed individuals."
The degree

of explicit verbal denial

is,

however, only one

personality

aspect affecting the behavioral response to treatment. 0n the basis of the

present data and methods of analysis a broader view of personality patterns in

relation to improvement with
as

clinically

EST

is

now

possible.

improved are characterized by such

Those

patients

who

are rated

features as: l) non-empathic

- unable to think critically or sensitively about the needs,feelings, or

-

commun-

ications of others; 2) non-introspective - - unable to think critically about
their own feelings or needs; unable to achieve insight even with the collaboration of others in a psychotherapeutic relationship; 3) rely heavily on nonverbal communication - - even

tial

when

they are talkative there is

little

referenp

communication, the words being cliched, stereotyped, or representative of

feelings and emotions rather than transmitters of information and h) highly
conventional - - without imaginative or creative capacity, and with few resources
to deal with stressful or
With
re8pond

new

this pattern as the

situations.

common

background, two classes of patients who

to treatment can be defined: a) the driving, conscientious, independent,

successful, emotionally-controlled person who can be characterized as the ”explicit verbal denial” personality type; b) the chronically inadequate, affectd::;;;&amp;rfrom
and
ively labile
ludic, dependent person,
an impoverished socio-

cultural background. While both types are rated as improved in their short
tenm response to electroshock, preliminary folloWhup observations indicate that
the "explicit verbal denial" personality type

clinical response, while the Indie

group

is

more

likely to sustain the

is likely to relapse quickly.

�Consistent with our previous studies

we have

found that altered brain fun-

ction is a necessary condition for behavioral change with electroshock therapy.
The kinds of behavioral change shown with altered brain function, however, vary
markedly in

different patients.

ment of symptoms and are

states,

become withdrawn,

Some Show mood

rated as improved. Others develop paranoid agitated
or show additional somatic or

are rated as unimproved. In this study

in those cases

we

who were

memory

complaints, and

here stressed the personality factors

whose behavioral reSponse was

considered the patients

changes and denial or diSplace-

rated as improved.

we have

not

rated as only moderately improved or unimproved.

If the basic hypothesis is correct,

we

should also find a relationship between

personality and the behavioral response in patients

who

are rated as unimproved.

Present information in this regard is minimal, as this problem has not'been
approached with a specific hypothesis.

raise questions concerning the relation of personality
to type of mental illness and choice of therapy. Clinical observations support
These observations

the concept of a characteristic predepressed personality. Abraham (I) noted

that states of depression occurred in obsessional persons. Arnot ‘2) describes
depressions as being overly conscientious and perfectionistic. Hamilton and

(5), reporting various aspects of the personality in involutional depression, include such features as "followed a rigid pattern of behavior....displayed a lack of imagination....narrow range of interests....thorough, cone

Mann

scientious, meticulous devotion to duty....lack of feeling for point of view
of others....hard, uncompromising drivers....oversensitive....reserved.“ Cohen,

et

a1 (3)

in an intensive study of manic-depressive psychosis, reported their

patients as being highly prestige-conscious;

little

concerned with prdblems of

interpersonal relatedness; stereotyped; conventional; having

for communicative interchange; and

unaware of

little

capacity

other persons' feelings toward

�.10himself or of his feelings toward others. They emphasized the patients' inability

to communicate verbally and suggested that the therapeutic relationship should
be in nandverbal terms rather than emphasizing the intellectual contents of the
exchange.
These studies of the personality background of depression show a

that is

pattern

similar to those personality asPects which have been described as
the "explicit verbal denial" personality. The factor of personality could thus
most

explain the fact that depression is the condition which responds best to electroshock treatment.

The same

personality factors which

to a depressive reaction are those which
forms of therapy.

These

factors enable

make him

him

make

a person susceptible

responsive to noneverbal

to respond, under the conditions

of altered brain function, with those language and other behavioral changes
which are evaluated as improved.

Thus, the same stereotypy, conventionality,

perfectionism, and prestige-consciousness, which produce a catastrophic response in the individual faced by the loss of a partner, job, business, or
loved one permit the development of denial, minimization and displacement under

the conditions of altered brain function and are deemed ”improved” by the family
and the

therapist.

�SUMMARY AND CONCLUSIONS

1. Personality factors in

63

consecutive patients referred for electro-

shock therapy were studied by means of a structured family interview.

2.

The

3.

The

which

results

that aSpects of personality can be differentiated
are significantly related to the response to treatment.
show

basic personality pattern of the patients who reSpond best can
be characterized as a) non-empathic, b) non-introspective, c) communicate non-

verbally, and d) highly conventional and stereotyped, with
or creative capacity.
h. 'Within the context of this
of improved patients.

One

group

is

common

little

imaginative

core, there are two main subdivisions

comparable to the

”explicit verbal denial"

personality, showingiﬁzch features as drive, conscientiousness, independence
and emotional control. The other group consists of persons apt to be chron-

ically inadequate

and dependent, coming from deprived socio-cultural back-

grounds, who are affectively

5.

labile

and

ludic.

relationship between these personality patterns and descriptions
of the personality of depressed persons is noted. The same personality factors
The

which contribute

to a depressive reaction, contribute to a behavioral change
under the conditions of altered brain function following electroshock therapy

which

is evaluated as

improvement.

�~12REFEEENCES

1. Abraham, K.: Selected Papers
Press Ltd., 1919.
Amot,

on

Psychoanalysis.

London: The Hogarth

Predepressed Personality, A.M.A. Arch. Neural.
Chiato, L6: 617-618, 1956.
The

12.:

&amp;

Psy-

3.,

Baker, G., Cohen, R. A., From—Reichmam, F. and Weigert,
E. V.: In Intensive Study of Twelve Cases of Manic-Depressive
Psychosis, Psychiat., 1.1: 103-137, 1951.

Cohen, M.

Pink,

and Kahn, R. L.:

Quantitative Studies of Slow Wave Activity
Following Electroshock, EEG Clin. Neurophysiol., Q: 158, 1956.

M.

Hamilton, D. M. and Mann, W. A.: The Hospital Treatment of Involutional
Psychoses, in Depression (Hock, P. and Zubin, J. , eds.) , New York:
Grune &amp; Stratton, 199-209, 1952.

L., Fink, M. and Weinstein, E. A.: Relation of Amobarbital
Test to Clinical Improvement in Electroshock, 11.14.11. Arch. Neurol.
&amp; Psydliato, 16-: 23-29, 1956.

Kahn, R.

7. Kahn, R. L. and Fink, 14.: Changes in Language During Electroshock Therapy, in Psychopatholog of Commication (Hock, P. and Zubin, J. ,
Eds.) in press.
‘

8. Piaget,

J.: Play,

Dreams and

Imitation in Childhood.

New

York: W. W.

9. Weimtein, E. 1., Linn, L. and Kahn, R. L.: Psychosis During Electroshock Therapy: Its Relation to the Theory of Shock Therapy, Am.

J.

PSYChiato’

3:99.:

22.26, 1952.

10. Weinstein, E. A., Kahn, R. L., Sugaman, L. A. and Linn, 1a.: Diagnostic
Use of Amobarbital Sodium ("Anwtal Sodium") in Organic Brain Dis-

ease,

ll. Weinstein,

Am.

J. Psychiat., 113:

889-891;, 1953.

E. A. and Kahn, R. L.: Personality Factors in Denial of
&amp;
A.M.A.
Arch.
Neural.
Psychiat., 92: 355-367, 1953.
ness,

Ill-

Weinstein, E. A., Kahn, R. L. and Sugarman, L. A.: Ludic Behavior in
Patients with Brain Disease, J. Hillside Hosp. , 2: 98-106, 1951;.
13. Weinstein, E. A. and Kahn, R. L.: Denial of Illness: Symbolic and Physiological Aspects. Springfield, 111.: Charles C. Thomas, 1955.

�April 1, 1957.
MEMORANDUM

TO:

Medical Affairs Committee

FOR:

Dr. Joseph S. A. Miller

FROM:

Department of Experimental Psychiatry

SUBJECT:

1957.
1956
to
April
1,
September
of
Departmental
Activities,
Report

Experimental
of
the
Department
of
the
of
activities
following report
since
the
period
covering
of’Dr.
Miller,
the
submitted
request
at
Psychiatry is
The

September 1956.
A.

Progress in Ongoing Projects:

the
evaluate
The
signifito
control
study
Evaluation:
1. Electroshock
be
com1956,
will
on
April
1,
instituted
electroshock
therapy,
cant elements in
been
has
been
have
studied.
It
1957.
Seventy
patients
pleted by the end of’May
the
electrointo
insights
have
we
and
gained
significant
successful
a most
group,
made
1955-56,
in
observation,
the
we
original
verified
shock process. First,
dethe
is
electroshock
therapy
behavior
in
in
change
that the prerequisite for
function.
brain
in
and
sustained
alteration
degree
velopment of a significant
Under the conditions of altered brain function, however, patients respond in
electroshock
is
follows
that
the
improvement
In
some
patients,
various ways.
the

that
was
opinion
our
It
disappears.
rapidly
while
in
others, it
sustained,
observations.
these
determinant
in
instrumental
the
was
patient's personality
in
the
of
patients
the
personality
studied
have
intensively
we
For this reason
standard
interview
developed
tests,
this last group. By applying specially
have
we
number
of
questionnaire
tests,
and
a
modifying
psychological tests,
and
of
type
between
personality
the
number
of
relationships
determined a
behavioral
the
we
At
predicting
are
time,
the present
behavioral response.
and
during
our
predictions
electroshock
to
therapy,
the
of
patients
response
As
a
result
chance.
than
better
been
have
months
significantly
the past few
include
to
personality
extend
study
our
to
we
planning
are
of these observations,
G).
Section
(see
results
psychotherapy
in
factors
changes
the
been
has
perceptual
of
patients
Our second interest in this group
to
deable
have
been
we
control
of
a
By
group,
virtue
induced by electroshock.
and
those
treatment
the
to
related
which
are
changes
termine those perceptual
im—
been
have
we
In
these observations,
which are related to practice effects.
and
their
the
of
the
patients
personality
close
interrelation.bf
the
pressed by
two
so
behavior
of
is
The
these
of
aspects
interrelation
perceptual processes.
in
differences
individual
of
undertake
study
a
decided
have
to
we
close, that
under
the
behavior
eventual
to
such
differences
and
to
relate
hope
perception
0).
Section
(see
function
brain
of
altered
special conditions
Our

which
electroshock
therapy
of
concept
a
to
have
led
develop
us
studies

Electrotreatment
unit.
of
this
management
the
in
has been of significant help
which
function
brain
in
induces
changes
treatment.
It
shock is a non-specific
Under
these
two
months.
than
less
of
usually
time,
persist for varying lengths
depending
environment
different
in
ways
to
his
the
responds
patient
conditions,
his
he
to
better
'With
relates
certain
a
personality,
upon his personality.

�-2The
and
better that he relates to
to
other
his
patients.
family,
therapist,
other people the less reason is there-for him to become tense, anxious or
6nce
the feeling of well-being is set into motion, it is sustained
depressed.
by the patient's better ability to function with others. Electroshock therapy
is not a specific treatment for a specific fbrm of mental illness.
2. Biochemical Changes in Electroshock: In the course of these studies
of electroshock, we noted that other investigators had reported that there were
and
the
one report
fluid
after
in
trauma,
in
Spinal
changes
enzymes
specific
noted similar changes after electroshock. Dr. Goldenberg and I undertook a
study of these enzymes in order to verify the previous reports and to clarify
our own picture of the electroshock process. To date, we have collected 30
spinal fluids. I anticipate that this phase of the work will continue until

the end of 1957.

3. Communication Studies: Our interest in communication problems has
led to two types of studies. In one, Dr. J. Jaffe has developed a technique for
the analysis of recorded interviews which provides us with an objective index of
change in behavior. Support for this phase of the work has been obtained from
the Foundations' Fund for Research in Psychiatry. At present, he is analyzing
the recordings of interviews with electroshock patients made earlier in the year,
and his findings are correlating very well with the clinical results. we antiand
the
in
of
language
changes
to
an
technique
analysis
this
applying
cipate
behavior that occur in ps;chotherapeutic interviews.

analysis of the structured amytal test intero
views according to changes in syntax and content. The original findings of this
study were presented to the AmeriCan Psychopathological Association in June.
Since then, all our amytal test interviews are being analyzed in like fashion
and the original findings have been verified and amplified. ”e have come to
understand that the language of our patients tells us readily whether or not
changes have occurred in brain function and in behavior. Furthermore, correlations between the personality evaluations and the language changes have shown
a direct relationship between high degree language changes and certain personwith
other personality types.
and
changes
minimal-to-no
language
types;
ality
Language is thus a recordable facet of behavior and we are ODtlmiStiC that a
combination of the language analyses developed by Drs. Jaffe and Kahn would be
a meaningful index of changes in behavior applicable to any form of psychiatric
therapy, including psychotherapy.
h. Egrebral Reactivity: As described in the previous report, our
interest in the question of individual variability in cerebral reactivity has
been stimulated by our electroshock studies. One part of this study is the
A second is the study of the
biochemical
in
changes
fluid.
of
spinal
study
rate of development of electroencephalographic change induced by electroshock.
Dr. Green has begun this phase of the work and since September has surveyed all
EEG
basic
of
their
by
records, and their
an
electroshock
analysis
our
patients
been
has
Mcgimide
to
the
cerebral
to
Also,
response
hyperventilation.
reSponse
A

second study

is

a language

assessed and this phase of the work completed (see Section B). Beginning in May,
the
admissions
new
hOSpital
the
to
that
will
screen
is
laboratory
anticipated
it
and that various activation procedures will be tested, so that the definitive
study can be undertaken in the Fall.

Concurrently, Dr. Green has assessed the relationship between the electroshock seizure threshhold and cranial resistance as factors influencing the development of electroencephalographic abnormality. This study is in progress.

�.3This study, under the direction of Dr. Sidney TaraNew
York
have
and
been
before
the
the
observations
continued
has
presented
chow,
Neurological Society in January. The observations have been summarized in a reand
A.M.A.
Archives
of
which
Neurology
the
in
Psychiatry.
will
shortly
appear
port
S.

B.

Ambivalence:

Completed

Projects:

1. Chlorpromazine-Insulin

Coma:

Control Study: An interim report on the results of this
control study was submitted to the Research Committee of the Medical Board on
January 31, 1957. In this study, 59 patients referred for insulin coma were
divided into two groups - one-half receiving insulin coma and the other half
receiving chlorpromazine therapy. It was our conclusion that chlorpromazine
is as effective in modifying psychotic behavior patterns as insulin coma therapy.
There was a tendency for the discharge ratings to be better for the chlorpromazine
,we
to
concluded
insulin
in
comparison
coma
the
than
for
insulin
that,
group.
group
coma therapy, chlorpromazine was safer, easier to administer, more controllable in
had
Tb
evidence
concluded
had
no
also
and
that
fewer
side
effects.
apits effects,
peared in the fifteen months of the study that either therapy had altered the basic
schizophrenic process, nor did we feel that either form of therapy had a greater
specificity for schizophrenic illnesses. At the conclusion of the study, the
Medical Director placed chlorpromazine in the formulary and permitted its use by
the Resident staff.

Insulin

Coma

2. Megimide Evaluation: During this period, Dr. Green has evaluated a
new agent in electroencephalography, megimide, for its ability to bring out defects in brain function. The report of his findings Twere presented at the midwinter meeting of the Eastern Association of Electroencephalographers.

0.

Projected Studies

It is

.

1957-58:

in progress in the Department will
The electroshock evaluation study will
be completed this Spring and the next few months will be spent in correlating
the information obtained and writing the reports. As indicated in the ongoing
and
have
of
studies
these
out
number
of
developments
grown
it
a
progress notes,
is anticipated that these will be incorporated in the_active research program.
anticipated that the work
continue for the remainder of the year.

now

A
Behavioral
Reapgggg:
protocol has been
1. £ndividual_Differences in
developed by Dr. Max Pollack, which incorporates the problem of personality affecting individual responsivity to electroshock. By determining the subject's patterns
of perception in specially developed orientation and visual tasks, we hope to demonstrate a relationship between these patterns and the behavioral response, both
under the special condition of altered brain function, and the general condition
of hospitalization and psychotherapy. Such a study has bearing on the problems of
the personality aspects of resistance to change in behavior under stressful conditions (as in forceful indoctrination, isolation, starvation); as well as the
definition of suitable candidates for various psychiatric therapies.

2. Personality Factors in Doctor and Patient Affecting Choice of Thera :
Our experiences with electroshock have led us to a unmber of hypotheses which relate personality factors in the patient and the therapist affecting the choice of
treatment. We are in the process of developing our ideas into a workable hypothesis.
We anticipate undertaking such a study by the end of the year.

�D.

Changes

in rersonnelz-

Since the last re\ort, this section has been redesignated as the Department
the
of
time
the
at
the
to
personnel
In
addition
listed
of Experimental Psychiatry.
Max
Research
Dr.
as
Pollack,
a
have
on
we
part-time
basis,
appointed,
last report,
New
York
from
who
University
has
his_Ph.D.
Dr.
Pollack,
Assistant in Psychology.
and
mount
the
Sinai
Hospital
the
at
research
been
has
psychologist
a
in 1955,
He
is experienced
the
six
for
Research
Child
past
years.
Ittleson Foundation for
he
that
is
anticipated
research.
in
and
It
perceptual aspects
in both personality
A
the
indito
study
July
on
program
basis
a
full-time
be
on
lst.
appointed
will
and
the
on
perceptual
personemphasis
with
behavior
specific
vidual differences in
made
various
been
has
to
and
him
been
application
by
developed
ality aspects has
foundations for support.

Technical
a
the
be
to
Department,
appointed
will
there
Effective April let,
FFRP
(see
Section
Grant
Under
the
of
terms
the
analyses.
Assistant for linguistic
E) funds were made available for a technical assistant to carry out the language
measurements devised by Dr. Jaffe.
E.

Funds:

Foundations' Fund for Research in Psychiatry has granted Dr. Jaffe
continuation
overhead
for
h5,700
a26,000
of
sum
plus
two
the
in
years
support for
the
been
has
developed
during
which
past year.
Dyad"
the
of
"Languahe
the
of
study
FFRP
The
Kaufmann
Foundation.
grant will exthe
This work had been supported by
tend from April 1, 1957 to March 31, 1959.
Health
Mental
fbr
of
National
made
Institute
the
been
to
have
Applications
subthe
Green.
Dr.
protocol
Also,
work
by
undertaken
of
support for the program
of
Division
and
Development
Research
the
to
been
has
sent
Pollack
mitted by Dr.
FoundaMalina
and
the
to
Army,
States
United
the
of
the Surgeon-General's Office
The

tion.

F.

Publications and rresentations:

In November, a summary of our studies on electroshock was presented at the
Montreal
a
in
Association
in
report
American
the
Psychiatric
of
Meeting
Divisional
FollowChange
Behavioral
to
Function
Brain
Altered
entitled "Relation of Tests of
"Electroencephalothe
Green
Dr.
report
December,
presented
Electroshock".
In
ing
Electroenceh
of
Association
Eastern
the
Negimide"
at
of
Lffects
and
Clinical
graphic
studies
during
the
of
electroencephalographic
In
a
summary
February
phalographers.
Differences
in
"Individual
entitled
a
two
in
was
report
presented
the past
years
EEG Besponsivity" before the Metropolitan EEG Society.
The Department has submitted a number of reports to various societies for the
the
at
for
been
have
presentation
accepted
Summer
Papers
and
meetings.
Spring

the
Psychiatry,
of
Biological
Society
the
Research
Association,
Electroshock
International Congress of Psychology and the International Congress for Psychiatry.
American
the
Psysymposia
at
in
to
been
have
invited
participate
In addition, we
These
meetings.
for
Psychiatry
International
Congress
and
chiatric Association
Department
of
this
the
experiences
considerable
detail
summarize
in
reports will
and
to
electroshock
to
with
regard
and
two
one-half
specific
the
years,
past
over
methods
of
the
language
anato
have
we
present
an
opportunity
also
will
drugs.
to
as
some
of
our
speculations
well
as
presenting
Dr.
as
devised
by
Jaffe,
lysis
the role and mode of action of the newer drug therapies in psychiatry.

�G.

Educationi_

Various members of this Department are continuing their education by
formal courses. Dr. H. Korin has been enrolled in courses at the Graduate
School of New York University with specific emphasis on statistics. Dr. J.
Jaffe is completing the formal training requirements at the William Alanson
White Institute of Psychoanalysis. Dr. Robert L. Kahn has been accepted for
training in psychoanalysis at the William Alanson White Institute.
H.

Other Activities:

1.

Israel Strauss

November 1953.

and

Members

Volume:

The

Israel Strauss

Volume appeared

in

of this Department were active in the development

fulfillment of that volume.

2. Resident Training: Since September 1956, two Residents have worked
H.
Esecover has been studying the problem of
Dr.
the
in
Department.
actively
psychotherapy with electroshock patients. In this study he has been supervised
He
made.
has
have
been
number
conclusions
and
of
a
members
the
Deiartment
of
by
demonstrated that patients differ considerably during the electroshock process
and that no single type of psychotherapy is meaningful. Certain supportive and
He is now in the process of
have
value.
definite
may
approaches
interpretive

describing his observations.

Dr. S. Friedman has contributed considerably to the ambivalence study.
this work he was supervised by Dr. Tarachow.

In

During the period September to February, members of the Department participated in a weekly lecture series for the Resident staff on the subjects of
research methodology and newer trends in psychiatry.

Respectfully submitted,
Max
MFzgw

Department of Experimental l’sychiatry
_

ﬂillside Hospital
Glen Oaks,

New

York

Fink,

M.D .

�HILLSIDE

HOSPITAL

FOR PSYCHIATRIC TREATMENT. TRAINING AND RESEARCH

JOSEPH S. A. MILLER,

75-59 263m:

M. D.

STREET. GLEN OAKS. NEw YORK
FIELD STONE

Medical Director

LEON

$7500

Lowwsrm

Honorary Chairman
Board of Directors

SIMON KWALWASSER, M. D.

ROY FOSTER

Assoc. Medical Director

Chairman
Board Of Directors

MAURICE BACHRACE

Administrator

E. COLEMAN
President

ALVIN

Dear Sir :

basis for the discussion of the research
activities at the meeting of the Medical Affairs
Committee on Monday, April 8th, I am herewith enclosing the following memoranda=
As a

1. Report of Dr. Fink for the Department of
Experimental Psychiatry.
2. Research activities in the Department of
Biochemistry, by Dr. Harry Goldenberg.

3. Research in the Department of Medicine,
by Dr. Arnold G. Blumberg

Aside from the regular Medical Board members of
the Medical Affairs Coxmnittee, there will also be present
Dr. H. L. Rachlin, Chairman of the Research Comittee of
the Medical Board and Dr. Max Fink, Director of the Department of Experimental t’sychia’cry.
Yours

sincerely,

f4,WIM,

Joseph S.A.Miller, M.D.

JSJALI:

11b

Medical Director

encl.

AN AFFILIATE OF FEDERATION OF JEWISH PHILANTHROPIES OF NEW YORK

�April 1, 1957.
MEMORANDUM

TO:

Medical Affairs Committee

FOR:

Dr. Joseph S. A. Miller

FROM:

Department of Experimental Psychiatry

SUBJECT:

Report of Departmental Activities,

September 1956 to April 1, 1957.

Experimental
of
the
Department
of
the
activities
of
following report
since
the
period
ofHDr.
covering
Miller,
the
request
Psychiatry is submitted at
The

September 1956.
A.

Proggess in Ongoing Projects:

the
evaluate
The
signifito
control
study
Evaluation:
1. Electroshock
be
com1956,
will
on
April
1,
instituted
electroshock
therapy,
cant elements in
been
has
studied.
been
have
It
pleted by the end ofTMay 1957. Seventy patients
the
electrointo
insights
have
we
and
significant
gained
a most successful group,
made
1955-56,
in
observation,
the
we
original
verified
shock process. First,
the
deis
electroshock
therapy
behavior
in
in
change
that the prerequisite for
function.
brain
in
and
sustained
alteration
velopment of a significant degree
Under the conditions of altered brain function, however, patients respond in
electroshock
is
follows
that
improvement
the
In
some
patients,
various ways.
that the

was
opinion
our
It
disappears.
rapidly
while
in
others, it
sustained,
observations.
these
in
determinant
instrumental
the
was
patient's personality
in
the
of
patients
the
personality
For this reason we have studied intensively
standard
interview
developed
tests,
this last group. By applying specially
have
we
number
of
questionnaire
tests,
a
and
modifying
psychological tests,
and
of
type
between
personality
the
number
of
relationships
determined a
behavioral
the
we
predicting
are
At
the present time,
behavioral response.
and
during
our
predictions
electroshock
therapy,
to
reSponse of the patients
As
a
result
chance.
than
better
been
have
significantly
the past few months
include
to
personality
extend
study
our
to
we
planning
are
of these Observations,
G).
Section
(see
results
factors in psychotherapy

changes
the
been
perceptual
has
of
patients
Our second interest in this group
deto
able
been
have
we
control
a
group,
induced by electroshock. By virtue of
and
those
treatment
the
to
which
related
are
termine those perceptual changes
imbeen
have
we
In
these
observations,
which are related to practice effects.
and
their
the
of
patients
the
personality
interrelation.of
close
the
pressed by
so
behavior
two
is
of
The
of
these
aspects
interrelation
perceptual processes.
in
differences
individual
of
undertake
study
a
decided
to
close, that we have
under
the
behavior
eventual
to
such
differences
and
to
relate
hope
perception
G).
Section
(see
function
brain
special conditions of altered
which
electroshock
therapy
of
a
concept
to
develop
have
led us
Our studies
Electrotreatment
unit.
this
of
management
the
in
has been of significant help
which
function
brain
in
changes
induces
shock is a non-specific treatment. It
Under
these
two
months.
than
less
of
usually
time,
persist for varying lengths
depending
environment
different
ways
in
his
to
responds
the
patient
conditions,
his
to
he
better
relates
With
certain
a
personality,
upon his personality.

�-2—

family, his therapist, and to other patients. The better that he relates to
other people, the less reason is there for him to become tense, anxious or
depressed. Once the feeling of well-being is set into motion, it is sustained
by the patient's better ability to function with others. Electroshock therapy
is not a specific treatment for a specific form of mental illness.
2. Biochemical Changes in Electroshock: In the course of these studies
of electroshock, we noted that other investigators had reported that there were
Specific changes in enzymes in the spinal fluid after trauma, and one report
noted similar changes after electroshock. Dr. Goldenberg and I undertook a
study of these enzymes in order to verify the previous reports and to clarify
our own picture of the electroshock process. To date, we have collected 30
spinal fluids. I anticipate that this phase of the work will continue until
the end of 1957.
Communication Studies:

interest in

communication problems has
led to two types of studies. Tn one, Dr. J. Jaffe has developed a technique for
the analysis of recorded interviews which provides us with an objective index of
change in behavior. Support for this phase of the work has been obtained from
the Foundations' Fund for Research in Psychiatry. At present, he is analyzing

3.

Our

the recordings of interviews with electroshock patients made earlier in the year,
and his findings are correlating very well with the clinical results. we antiand
the
in
of
language
changes
to
an
technique
analysis
this
applying
cipate
behavior that occur in pa chotherapeutic interviews.

analysis of the structured amytal test interviews according to changes in syntax and content. The original findings of this
study were presented to the American Psychopathological Association in June.
Since then, all our amytal test interviews are being analyzed in like fashion
and the original findings have been verified and amplified. We have come to
understand that the language of our patients tells us readily whether or not
changes have occurred in brain function and in behavior. Furthermore, correlations between the personality evaluations and the language changes have shown
a direct relationship between high degree language changes and certain personality types; and minimalvto-no language changes with other personality types.
Language is thus a recordable facet of behavior and we are optimistic that a
combination of the language analyses developed by Drs. Jaffe and Iahn would be
a meaningful index of changes in behavior applicable to any form of psychiatric
therapy, including psychotherapy.
h. Egrebral Reactivity: As described in the previous report, our
interest in the question of individual variability in cerebral reactivity has
been stimulated by our electroshock studies. One part of this study is the
A
second is the study of the
biochemical
in
of
changes
spinal fluid.
study
rate of development of electroencephalographic change induced by electroshock.
Dr. Green has begun this phase of the work and since September has surveyed all
our electroshock patients by an analysis of their basic EEG records, and their
reSponse to hyperventilation. Also, the cerebral response to Mcgimide has been
assessed and this phase of the work completed (see Section B). Beginning in May,
is anticipated that the laboratory will screen new admissions to the hospital
it
and that various activation procedures will be tested, so that the definitive
study can be undertaken in the Fall.
A

second study

is

a language

Concurrently, Dr. Green has assessed the relationship between the electroshock seizure threshhold and cranial resistance as factors influencing the development of electroencephalographic abnormality. This study is in progress.

�.3’
5. Ambivalence: This study, under the direction of Dr. Sidney TaraNew
York
have
before
been
and
the
the
observations
presented
chow, has continued
Neurological Society in January. The observations have been summarized in a report which will appear shortly in the A.M.A. Archives of Neurology and Psychiatry.
B.

Completed Progects:

1. Chlorpromazine-Insulin

Coma:

Control Study: An interim report on the results of this
control study was submitted to the Research Committee of the Medical Board on
January 31, 1957. In this study, 59 patients referred for insulin coma were
divided into two groups - one-half receiving insulin coma and the other half
receiving chlorpromazine therapy. It was our conclusion that chlorpromazine
is as effective in modifying psychotic behavior patterns as insulin coma therapy.
There was a tendency for the discharge ratings to be better fer the chlorprcmazine
we
concluded that, in comparison to insulin
coma
the
than
for
insulin
group.
group
coma therapy, chlorpromazine was safer, easier to administer, more controllable in
had
evidence
concluded
had
no
‘b
that
also
fewer
and
side
apeffects.
its effects,
peared in the fifteen months of the study that either therapy had altered the basic
schizophrenic process, nor did we feel that either form of therapy had a greater
specificity for schizophrenic illnesses. At the conclusion of the study, the
Medical Director placed chlorpromazine in the formulary and permitted its use by
the Resident staff.

Insulin

Coma

2. Megimide Evaluation: During this period, Dr. Green has evaluated a
new agent in electroencephalography, megimide, for its ability to bring out demidTJere
the
The
of
his
findinas
at
presented
function.
brain
in
report
fects
winter meeting of the Eastern.Association of Electroencephalographers.
C.

Projected Studies

7

l9§7~§8:

the
work
now
in
the
in
Department will
that
progress
anticipated
is
It
continue for the remainder of the year. The electroshock evaluation study will
be completed this Spring and the next few months will be spent in correlating

the information obtained and writing the reports. As indicated in the ongoing
and
have
of
studies
these
out
number
of
developments
grown
it
a
progress notes,
is anticipated that these will be incorporated in the active research program.
A
i“Response:
Behavioral
protocol has been
1. lgdividual Differences in
IVia}:
Dr.
Pollack, which incorporates the problem of personality affectdeveloped by
ing individual responsivity to electroshock. By determining the subject's patterns
of perception in specially developed orientation and visual tasks, we hOpe to demonstrate a relationship between these patterns and the behavioral response, both
under the special condition of altered brain function, and the general condition
of hospitalization and psychotherapy. Such a study has bearing on the problems of
the personality aspects of resistance to change in behavior under stressful conditions (as in forceful indoctrination, isolation, starvation); as well as the
definition of suitable candidates for various psychiatric therapies.

2. Personality Factors in Doctor and Patient Affecting Choice of Therapy:
Our experiences with electroshock have led us to a number of hypotheses which relate personality factors in the patient and the therapist affecting the choice of
treatment. We are in the process of developing our ideas into a workable hypothesis.
We anticipate undertaking such a study by the end of the year.
17

,

914.4 f 3
f

1

b

Va.

1,5

_.

�D.

Changes

in Fersonnel:

the
Department
been
as
has
redesignated
section
this
Since the last re ort,
the
time
of
the
at
listed
the
personnel
to
In
addition
of Experimental Psychiatry.
Max
Research
as
Dr.
Pollack,
a
basis,
last report, we have appointed, on part-time
New
York
University
from
Ph.D.
who
has
Dr.
Pollack,
his
Assistant in Psychologr.
and
the
mount
Sinai
Hospital
the
at
in 1955, has been a research psychologist
He
is experienced
six
the
Research
for
past
years.
Ittleson Foundation for Child
he
that
anticipated
is
It
in both personality and perceptual aspects in research.
A program to study the indiJuly
on
basis
lst. on the perceptual and personwill be appointed on a full-time
vidual differences in behavior with Specific emphasis
made
various
been
to
has
and
him
by
application
been
developed
ality aspects has

foundations for support.

Technical
a
the
Department,
to
be
appointed
will
there
Effective April lst,
FFRP
Section
(see
Grant
of
the
Under
terms
the
Assistant for linguistic analyses.
the
language
out
to
assistant
technical
a
carry
made
for
available
E) fUnds were
measurements devised by Dr. Jaffe.
3-

£211.42:

Dr.
Jaffe
has
granted
Fund
Research
Psychiatry
Foundations'
in
for
The
continuation
overhead
for
$5,700
u26,000
of
plus
sum
the
two
years in
support for
the
been
during
past
developed
has
which
year.
Dyad"
the
of
"Languace
the
of
study
FFRP
The
will
Fbundation.
exKaufmann
grant
the
by
been
had
work
supported
This
tend from April 1, 1957 to March 31, 1959.
Health
Mental
for
of
National
made
Institute
the
to
been
Applications have
subthe
Green.
protocol
Dr.
Also,
by
work
undertaken
support for the program of
of
Division
and
Development
Research
the
to
been
sent
mitted by Dr. Pollack has
FoundaMalino
and
the
to
Army,
States
United
the Surgeon-General's Office of the

tion.

F.

Publications and Presentations:

the
at
was
presented
electroshock
on
studies
of
our
In November, a summary
Montreal
a
in
Association
report
in
American
Psychiatric
the
of
Meeting
Divisional
FollowChange
Behavioral
to
Function
Brain
entitled "Relation of Tests of Altered
"Electroencephalothe
Green
report
Dr.
presented
December,
Electroshock".
In
ing
Electroenceb
of
Association
Eastern
the
Megimide"
of
at
graphic and Clinical Lffects
during
studies
electroencephalographic
the
of
In
a
February summary
phalographers.
Differences
in
"Individual
entitled
a
in
report
two
was
presented
the past
years
EEG Besponsivity" before the Metropolitan EEG Society.
the
for
societies
various
to
number
of
submitted
a
reports
The Department has
the
at
for
been
have
presentation
accepted
Summer
meetings. Papers
Spring and
the
Psychiatry,
Biological
of
Society
the
Research
Association,
Electroshock
for
Congress
Psychiatry.
International
and
the
Psychology
of
Congress
International
Psy—
American
the
symposia
at
in
In addition, we have been invited to participate
These
meetings.
for
Psychiatry
International
Congress
and
chiatric Association
Department
of
this
the
experiences
detail
considerable
summarize
in
reports will
and
to
electroshock
to
regard
with
and
one-half
specific
two
years,
over the past
methods
of
anathe
language
to
present
have
we
an
opportunity
also
will
drugs.
to
as
some
of
our
speculations
well
as
presenting
lysis devised by Dr. Jaffe, as
in
psychiatry.
therapies
the
newer
drug
of
mode
and
of
action
the role

�-5G.

Education:

Various members of this Department are continuing their education by
formal courses. Dr. H. Korin has been enrolled in courses at the Graduate
School of New York University with specific emphasis on statistics. Dr. J.
Jaffe is completing the formal training requirements at the William Alanson
White Institute of Psychoanalysis. Dr. Robert L. Kahn has been accepted for
training in psychoanalysis at the William Alanson White Institute.
H.

Other Activities:

1. Israel Strauss Volume:

November 1955.

and

Members

The

Israel Strauss

Volume appeared

in

of this Department were active in the development

fulfillment of that volume.

2. Resident Training: Since September 1956, two Residents have worked
H.
Dr.
Esecover has been studying the problem of
the
in
Departnent.
actively
psychotherapy with electroshock patients. In this study he has been supervised
He
has
made.
have
been
number
and
conclusions
of
a
members
of the Department
by
demonstrated that patients differ considerably during the electroshock process
and that no single type of psychotherapy is meaningful. Certain supportive and
He
of
the
now
have
in
value.
is
definite
process
may
approaches
interpretive

describing his observations.

Dr. S. Friedman has contributed considerably to the ambivalence study.
this yprk he was supervised by Dr. Tarachow.

In

During the period September to February, members of the Department participated in a weekly lecture series for the Resident staff on the subjects of
research methodology and newer trends in psychiatry.

Respectfully submitted,
Max
MFzgw

Department of Experimental i"sychiatry
&gt;

hillside Hospital
Glen Oaks,

New

York

Fink, M.D.

�April 1, 1957
Medical Affairs Cummittee

TO:

For: Dr. Joseph S.A.Miller
From:

Department of Biochemistry

Subject:

Report of Departmental Activities, July 1956 to March 31, 1957.

Steroid Studies
Studies were continued on the steroid hormones because of their importance
in the physiological response to stress. Experiments with rats showed that the
liver converts neutral and sex hormones to their sulfate conjugates which are
subsequently voided in the urine. Female rat~ liver was far more active than
male preparations in conjugating the steroids, particularly the male hormones.
These findings indicate that the liver plays a major role in the maintaining
hormonal balance, femalssbeing endowed with a regulatory device to dispose of
excess male hormones produced in their bodies.
Urinary steroid sulfate excretion studies on human subjects were carried out
The
and
total
chromatographic
techniques.
complexation
with our newly developed
sulfate output was found to be related to both sex and age. Interesting results
were obtained with urine from schizophrenics, the level of one fraction (dehydronumber
of cases.
elevated
sulfate)
in
a
being
epiandrosterone
Drugs and Alkaloids
New

colorimetric, chromatographic

electrophoretic techniques were establipsychothenpeutic drugs. These were recently

and

for both the psychotomimetic and
presented at the American Chemical Society
shed

Meeting (Brooklyn, February 15, 1957).

findings are now being applied to determining the role of trace urinary alkaloids in schizophrenia.
our earlier chlorpromazine studies, which were dropped for lack of suitable
instrumentation, are again under way with financial help from the National Institutes
much
throws
because
The
of
interest
it
light on
Health.
is
ver
great
of
subject
from
the
be
which
cannot
gained
(microsome
action
gross liver
function
liver
function tests in currentuse. we find the chlorpromazine molecule is in many ways
The
from
information
gleaned
to
some
in
isotopes.
ways
ideal
superior
an
tracer,
this study would also throw light on the Akerfeldt "six~minute blood test for
from
whether
suffer
a
decide
schizophrenics
should
to
and
us
help
schizophrenia"
defect in oxidative metabolism leading to the in vivo production of hailucinogens.
The

Electroshock
Lavels
Therapy.
in
gholinesterase

Earlier investi ations by Tower and others have indicated demonstrable changes
in acetylcholine, acetylcholinesterase, and pseudocholinesterase in spinal fluid
following electroshock therapy as well as other forms of head trauma. AccordingEEG
of
have
to
correlate
undertaken
Fink
patients
and
Ur.
patterns
associates
ly,
EST
values
cholinesterase
in
concurrent
and
with
alterations
after
during
before,
of spinal fluid. Simultaneous serum cholinesterase determinations on these patients
blood
red
to
extend
these
studies
and
cell
we
to
carried
plan
also
being
out,
are
(true)cholinesterase. The specific enzyme methods in use were developed at Hillside
Hospital and have recently been presented at the American Chemical Society Meeting
in Brooklyn. Further reference is made to Dr. Fink's progress report for findings
to date.
Future plans:

More

of the same.

Harry Goldenberg, Ph.D.

�April 1, 1957.
Medical Affairs Committee

TO

For: Dr. Joseph S.A.Miller
From:

Department of'Medicine

subject:

Report of Departmental Activities, July 1956 to March 31, 1957.

to
of
An
the
patients
of
psychiatric
Test:
response
l. Mecholylof mecholyl analysis
between
correlation
a
revealed
has
striking
subcutaneously
injections
electroshock
to
and
therapy.
and
diagnosis
response
age,
response
have
machine
blood
recording
automatic
of
an
studies
pressure
2. Preliminary
machine
for
and
of
this
the
evaluate
practicability
to
out
accuracy
been carried
now
seems
As
these
of
result
a
studies,
the
work
mecholyl
it
test.
on
further
of
the
evaluate
to
used
be
reproducibility
machine
usefully
can
likely that this
the mecholyl

test.

3. Drug evaluation studies on meprobamate are being carried out.
h. Chemical studies with the laboratory department are being conducted on possible
hepato-toxic effects of chlorpromazine in our patients.
Proposed Research for the coming year:

1. Evaluation of meprobamate in psychiatric patients.
three months).
2.

(to be completed within

Evaluation of reproducibility of mecholyl test employing a recording sphygmo-

mamometer.

by
chromatographic
with
therapy
chlorpromazine
alterations
of
Evaluation
3.
protein
techniques.

h. Evaluation of
or Trilafon.

a

substitute fbr chlorpromazine. This will be either Spaﬁine
Arnold Blumberg, M.D.

�HILLSIDE

HOSPITAL

FOR PSYCHIATRIC TREATMENT. TRAINING AND RESEARCH

JOSEPH S. A. MILLER,

75-59 263RD

M. D.

STREET. GLEN OAKS. NEw YORK
FIELDSTONE

Medical Director

LEON LOWENSTEIN

3-7800

Honorary Chairman
Board of Directors

M. D.
Assoc. Medical Director

SIMON KWALWASSER,

ROY FOSTER

Chairman
Board of Directors

MAURICE BACHRACH

E. COLEMAN
President

Administrator

ALVIN

A

Proposed Study

for the Behavioral

Max

From

Assay of

New

Drugs

Fink M.D.

the Department of Experimental PBychiatny

October 30, 1957.

AN AFFILIATE OF FEDERATION OF JEWISH PHILANTHROPIES OF NEW YORK

�AProposed Study for theBehavi9ralwg§§ay of

New

Dm
mgs

MaxFi‘nk M.D. *

1 . Problem:

is little disagreement that the newer psychopharmamode
of
these
drugs
of
action
the
behavior,
alter
cological agents
and factors in the marked individual variability in response are
unresolved problems. Difficulty in resolving these problems lies,
While there

in part, in the lack of a theoretic framework subject to operational
the
is
assay
perplexing
and
Particularly
experimentation.
analysis
of new, i;g., clinically untested agents capable of altering behavior.
Many

the
because
reports are
to
assess
studies
difficult
are
present

and
classifications
nosologic
defined;
the
poorly
population
subjective;

are unsatisfactory.
Based on our previous

studies,

we have

expressed the hypothesis

that the efficacy of psychopharmacological agents in psychotic states
measurable
changes
induce
to
persistent
to
their
related
ability
is
in cerebral function (1). Such alteration in cerebral function provides the milieu for changes in adaptation of the patient in his
environmento

In this view, alterations in cerebral function following

drug administration are not "complications," or "untoward

but the sing

SEE

293 of the

mode

effects,"

of action of these therapies.

Changes

condition
not
sufficient
but
a
a
cerebral
are
physiology
in
necessary,

for improvement.
* Director, Department of Experimental Psychiatry, Hillside Hospital,
Glen Oaks, N.Y.

�,2This hypothesis

is

a direct outgrowth of four years of experimental

investigations of electrcconvulsive, insulin

coma and

various drug

therapies in use at Hillside Hospital. These studies are summarized

in the appended report (1).
we have used a wide

t

variety of measures of brain function

(2, 3, h, 10, 12). Most successful have been changes in the frequency
spectrum of the

EEG,

patterns of language and perceptual tasks. In

our experiences with electroshock, slowing of
most

EEG

frequencies has been

helpful (2). In drug studies, however, this is less prominent,

although fundamental; Language and perceptual

tests,

however, have

given us clues as to ways of measuring brain changes, more subtle than

present electroencephalographic techniques.

It is

this study to
logic agents according to their effects
the purpose of

patterns and

on

perceptual tasks.

to test the following:

The

compare various psychopharmacoon

the

study

EEG, on

language

is specifically

designed

I

(a) Can the extent of behavioral change in psychopharmacologic
agents be related to the degree of
(b)

To

EEG

spectrum changes?

what extent can visual discrimination

measures of changes in language be

tests, and
refined to provide reliable,

predictablezueasures of changes in clinical behavior?
(c)

To what

extent can such measures predict the clinical

usefulness of psychopharmacologic agents?

�II.

Method:

1. Subjects:
All subjects are

drawn from the

adult impatient service

of the Hillside Hospital.

In general, these patients are

erative, well educated
good physical health.

intelligent. All are

and

alert,

coopT

ambulatory and in

2. Procedure:
Two

methods of drug assay are

in progress.

(a) Acutg_Experiments:

In the laboratory setting, with simultaneous

EEG

and

language recording in process, single intravenous or oral doses of
drugs are administered.

the period of drug

Patients are under constant observation for

activity.

(b) Clinical Experiments:

Patients are referred

by

their therapist to the super-

vising psychiatrist for treatment with psychopharmacologic agents.
Prior to drug administration,

EEG

and language recording interviews

are held. Perceptual tasks are completed. Drug administration then

until toxicity is manifest, and drug
reduced to a maintenance dose. Testing is repeated, and be-

proceeds
dosage

at

a rapid increment

havioral observations made, at frequent, defined intervals.

in previousstudies, subjects are randomly divided into

As

groups

-

an experimental and a

control.

The

experimental group

receives the medication, the control group placebo medication.

two

�3. measurements:
(a)

33.29.

is

Recording with an 8 channel Medcraft instrument

in progress. Records have been visually analyzed for changes in
frequency, voltage, symmetry and rhythmicity (2). Activation by
hyperventilation is routine.

validity of other activating
and
photic
hypoglycemia
megimide
(6),
intravenous
as
procedures
The

stimulation is being assessed.
(b) Perceptual.
Within the past decade certain perceptual procedures
have been shown to be

(11, 12, 13).

sensitive measures of cerebral dysfunction

Such techniques as

critical flicker fusion

(OFF), and

"embedded"
of
figures
polychromatic
the tachistoscopic recognition

in a
These

visual background are being assessed (10, 12, 13).
measures have the adVantage of giving a reliable quantitative

complex

measure of pretreatment functioning

in terms of a continuous variable,

rather than the qualitative dichotomy of "normal" versus "abnormal;"
imposing no undue

stress

on the

patient;

and the apparatus and

pro-

relatively inexpensive.
1) Critical flicker fusion SCFFZ: As the rate of
the
that
the
illusion
there
develops
of
increased,
flicker light is
point
this
at
of
The
the
light
flickering
frequency
steady.
is
light
cedure are simple, convenient and

is

the CFF. The

CFF

threshold is measured using a Sylvania glow

ratio is
brightness is varied to robtain thresholds at different

tube pulsed by an electronic power supply. The light—dark

fixed,

and

�-5-

levels.

The psychophysical method of

is

descending steps

limits using ascending

and

employed.

2) Tachistoscopic recognition of pseudoisochromatic

gigures:

The H—R-R

pseudoisochromatic plates (American Optical Company) con~

sisting of a series of cards with numerous small circles of various
sizesare used. The circles vary in color, and form outlines of
various geometric patterns, as ring, cross and triangle. These

patterns form a "figure"

on a

constant background. The

"neutral" plates are recognized by

all subjects -

blind." These plates have been photographed and
projection slides.

initial

normal and "color-

mounted as 2" x 2"

of exposure which permits accurate

The speed

identification of the figure is the index used.
(0)

Eggggggg.

Interviews with patients are recorded. Both unstructare
The
records
analyzed
included.
and
ured
structured periods are

for diversity (7) of the dyadic speech.
been found useful in analysis of changes in

for changes in syntax (9),
These methods have

and

behavior with other therapies.
(d) Evaluation of

clinical changes.

Psychiatric evaluations are

made

at fixed intervals

as to type and degree of changes in behavior, and a rating of
"improvement"
and

is

made.

in "improvement" are

The methods
now

of rating both change in behavior

under study.

Present ratings have been

based on the Malamud-Sands Rating Scales and have been of limited

usefulness.

The

present descriptive statements of the evaluator,

�-6following an outline of specific areas of behavior combined with
a review of the nurses' and resident

therapist's notes is being

continued.

h. Pharmacologic Agents:
Previous experience with amobarbital (8), megimide (6),

reserpine (IA) and chlorpromazine (5) provides the background for
the selection of new agents. At present, acute study of diethazine
(SKF 1026-A)

is in progress. Clinical studies of

meprobamate,

perphenazine and chlorpromazine are under investigation.
have been formulated

reaponse.

to test other agents, with different

spectral

Available:

The Department

of Experimental Psychiatry was established at the

Hillside Hospital in l95h.

clinical duties.

EEG

.

-

III. Facilities

Plans

of the department have no

Members

They devote

their full

at the institution to

time

the research prognmns.

Eight rooms of laboratories and offices in the principle medical

building of the hospital are provided. These include:
a)

EEG

Laboratory - equipped with Medcraft

encephalograph and Grass photic-stimulator.
on a

A

8

channel Electro-

technician is employed

full-time research basis.
b)

Psychophysical Laboratory

-

Two

Grass stimulators, Dumont

oscilloscope and step-up transformer power supply in a rack-mounted
assembly.

This equipment has been used for the past three years to

study threshold
and

after

for

simultaneous

tactile stimuli of patients before

induced states of altered cerebral function.

�.37.-

A

tachistoscopic assembly consisting of

two

projectors,

solenoidaactivated shutters, and opal glass screen is in use.
c) Psxcholinggistic Laboratogz:

A

third laboratory has been

established for the recording of interviews.
a Magnecord tape

recorder,

two

It is

equipped with

and
mixer.
microphones,
Electrovoice

auxilliary recorders for transcription are available.
The
available
for
study.
All patients in the hospital are
research programs have been well integrated into the hospital

Two

milieu so that manipulation of experimental variables are readily
accomplished.

�and Reggrts:

Iv. Publications

l.
2.

of
Physiodynamic
Action
of
the
Unified
Theory
Fink,
Therapies, J. Hillside Hosp. (in press).
M. : A

and Kahn, R.L.:' Relation of EEG Delta Activity to
Behavioral Response in Electroshock: Quantitative
Serial Studies, A.M.A. Arch. Neurol. and Pachiat.

(in press).

3.
h.

m:

Diffuse
of
Effects
and
H.:
Korin,
,
Altered Brain Function in Perception. Read at XV Int'l
Congress of Paychology, Brussels, 1957.
,

:

,

Relation of Tests of

Altered Brain Function to Behavioral Change Following
mectroshock. Read at the A.P.A. Divisional Meeting,
Montreal, November, 1956.

5.

and Coleman, F.S.:
Coma
and
Insulin
of
Chlorpromazine
Comparative Study
in the Therapy of Psychosis, J. Amer. Med. Assoc.

, Shaw, R., Cross,

6.,

(in press).

6. Green,

Fink, M.:

Megimide, EEG.

7.

Jaffe, J.:

Clinical Effects of

W

M.A. and
An

EEG

and

Clin. Neuromvsiolu g: 180-181, 1957.

Objective Study of Communication in Psychiatric

Interviews, J. Hillside Hosp. (in press).
8. Kahn, R.L., Fink, M. and Weinstein, E.A.: Relation of
Amobarbital Test to Clinical Improvement in Electro8c Psvchiat.
1956.
23-29,
Meurol.
A.M.A.
Arch.
lé:
shock,
9.

10.

ll.

Durinf-j Ele ctroLanguage
Changes
in
,
of Cormnunication,
shock Therapy, in P cho tholo
Ein
press).
Crune and Stratton
:

Em‘oedded Figures After
of
Perception
,
Induced Altered Brain Function, Am. Psychol” 1.3: 361
(Abst.) 1957.
:

Effects of Visual, Vestibular and Somatosensorimotor Deficit on Autokinetic Perception, J. @332.
§_2_: 398~LLlO, 1956 (with Battersby, 11.3.,
Pszchol.,

Pollack,

Mr:

Kahn, R.L. and Bender, 15.8.)

�0-9-

12. Pollack, M.: Tachistoscopic Identification of Contour in
Patients with Brain Damage, J, Cam . Ph 101.
szchol., 50: 220-227, 1957, {with Battersby,‘W.S.
and Bender, M.B.)

13.

Visual Deficit After Brain Damage in Man
as Measured with Rapidly Exposed Chematic Stimuli,
Amer. Peyphol., 12: h68,(Abst.) (with Battersby,‘w.s.
:

and Bender, M.B{7:

1h. WachSpress, M., Blumberg, A.G., Fink, M. and Miller,J.S.A.:
Evaluation of High Dose Reserpine Therapy for Relief
of Anxiety, J. Hillside HOSE. 5: 67-77, 1956.

�.10V.

Financial Support:
Support for the ongoing programsof the Department of Experimental

'

Psychiatry

is

provided by U.S, Public Health M-927, (Altered Brain

Function Following Electroshock), the Foundations' Fund for Research

in Psychiatry grant 56-151

(Language of the Dyed), and the Board of

Directors' Research Fund.

The

proper development of the specific

aspects of this protocol require support for the following, for a
two

year period.

19 8

Dr. M. P01130k, PhoD.
Senior Research Asst. Psychology
EEG

$
_

Technician - Hrs. Hannah Hosquera

12§9

8,250

$
‘

8,750

3,720

3,8u0

2,000

2,000

50

th

50

th

200

300

Equipment: (Over 2 year period).

Analyzer (Edin)
Flicker Fusion Apparatus

EEG

Projector, Slides
Calculator

(h,000)
(800)
(100)
(880)

hDO

hOO

Travel:
)
(Amer. Psychol. Assoc.
(Amer. Psychiatric ASSOC.)

$ 15,060

Overhead (15%)
TOTAL

$

d

15,h80

2,26h

2,327

17,32h

n 17,807

'

�\

KILLSIIE mSPITAL
Glen Oaks, NOYO

January 27, 1958.
MORAN!!! '10:

Medical Affairs Committee

FOR:

Joseph

FRCM:

Merimental Psychiatry
1958.
January
1957
1,
to
1,
Report of Activities, April

Miller,

M.D.

Deparhxent of

SUBJECT:

I.

30 A.

-~.—--

INTROIIJCTION:

achieved
has
professional
work
Department
the
of
the
nine
months,
In the past
various
of
understanding
We
our
reflecting
have
presented reports
recognition.
and
these
and
international
societies,
national
before
physiodynamic therapies
October
the
in
work
were
presented
of
Five
our
aspects
have been well received.
psychiatric
by
been
leading
have
accepted
and
other
Journal
reports
the
of
issue
Journals and will appear in 1958-59.
convulmode
of
of
action
the
of
Our studies have given us a clear picture
confidence
to
has
us
given
information
ibis
coma
and
therapies.
insulin
sive
to
these
in
therapies
which
were
fruitful
and
techniques
extend the hypotheses
behavioral
concerning
a
ideas
in
protocols
have
expressed our
drug therapy. We
Psychothe
both
by
received
been
well
These
having
new
ideas,
of
drugs.
assay
comand
various
pharmaceutical
U.S.P.H.S.
the
of
Center
Research
pharmacology
1958.
for
studies
new
the
in
been
implemented
have
panies,
.

, .
therapy, we were

,

.

.

number
a.
of
ancillary
led
to
electroshock
In evaluating
The
value
for
psychiatry.
have
which
basic
significance
broad,
investigations
found
and
assessed
were
change
behavioral
of
indices
of language measures as
While
a
studied.
"improvement"
was
The
of
defining
problem
satisfactory.
been
has
approach
operational
an
accomplished,
not
was
satisfactory resolution
which
the
criteria
Also,
studies.
recent
defined which was successful in our
has
an
to
led
Hillside
at
various
the
therapies
for
determine patient referral
of
choice
therapy.
factors
and
affecting
psychologic
the
sociologic
evaluation of

In addition, the ability of this department personnel to work together has
been
have
the
in
hospital
and
Our
relationships
roles
been amply demonstrated.
hosthe
from
at
staffs
all
cooperation
excellent
defined and we have received

pital.
II. PROGRESS IN
(A)

ONGOING PROJECTS:

Therapy Evaluations:

l.

Flectroshock.

We
electroshock
therapy.
Our studies have defined the process of
physiology;
brain
in
induced
changes
the
to
behavioral
the
have related
response
behavioral
of
the
type
affect
that
and
factors
sociologic
described personality
and
clinical
behavioral
between
response
the
and
defined
relationship
response;
of
various
the
types
to
relate
us
These
studies
permit
ratings of improvement.
PM
1090), electroshock and its varieties,
(metrazol
3,
convulsive therapy as drug
"convulsive
there.
of
concept
(Indoklon)
meaningful
into
a
and lately, inhalant
,

pies '.

�-2Based on these studies, reasonable criteria for the type of patient
"do well" with convulsive therapy can be defined. Continuing studies

will
behavioral
the
in
of
role
the
personality
amplify
designed.to
in this area are
non-electroshock
referbetween'out-patient
differences
the
define
to
response;
convulsive
inhalant
of
and
evaluation
an
(IIIc)
rals and in~patient populations
'

who

therapy (111a).
2.

.

£235 Therapy.

control
coma-chlorpromazine
insulin
of
conclusion
our
the
Following
1958.
and
.A.M.A.
in
early
will
appear
study, our report was accepted by he J
the
experimental
program.for
have
developed
a
we
months,
six
the
During
past
which
begun
was
(see
IIIb),
agents
psychopharmacological
new
of
evaluation
3.

Selection of therapies:

of
the
based
on
type
generally
is
of
therapy
While the selection
the
Such
as
aspects
decisions.
such
affect
factors
mental disorder, other
and
cultural
education
his
communicate
verbally,
to
facility of the patient
have
we
and
been
have
studied,
"authoritarianism”
background, and the degree of
rebear
significant
a
and
aspects
psychologic
such
historical
reported that
These
services.
for
ancillary
lationship to the choice of therapy or referral
of
the
in
factors
these
of
results
studies have led to an interest in the role
socioof
role
the
evaluate
further
to
therapy, and we have designed a study
(see
IIIc).
and
therapy
outpatient
of
inpatient
psychologic factors in results
(B)

Language as measurable behavior:

one.
complex
"in
is
a
'improvement
psychiatry
of
definition
and
change
behavioral
of
In evaluation of various therapies, the definition
have
sought
we
adequate,
are
While
descriptions
clinical
improvement is crucial.
Two
methods
of
our
behavior
patients.
the
language
in
guides
more
objective
for
interviews
of
structured
analysis
of analyses have been developed - a syntactic
and a dyadic of unstructured.
The

non-convulsive
and
convulsive
induced
by
changes
have described the
do
clinical
reflect
patterns
these
language
therapy, and find that changes in
to
these
techniques
of
the
have
application
to
led
Our
experiences
evaluation.
We

the drug evaluation studies.
effort
in
an
in
are
of
progress
language
other
analyses
In addition,
methods.
the
of
present
the
broaden
applicability
to
(C)
Neurophysiology of Behavior:
the
between
relationship
the
noted
we
In the electroshock studies
We
concluded
behavioral
response.
the
and
change
neurophysiologic
of
degree
and
behavior
in
change
to
a
essential
was
physiology
cerebral
in
change
that a
coma
therapy.
insulin
for
conclusion
We
same
the
come
had
to
to "improvement".
chlorpromazine
in
treatment
the
response
between
Since we had observed a similarity
was
mode
action
of
same
the
that
seemed
plausible
therapy and insulin coma, it
drugs.
newer
tranquilizing
the
for
operative

�-3review of the literature and some preliminary experiments supported
the
to
potent
are
agents
psychopharmacologic
newer
the
that
this hypothesis We
have
function.
brain
and
affect
predictably
extent that they measurably
and
in
of
Psychiatry
Congress
International
the
at
hypothesis
this
expressed
new
undertaken
have
we
As
a
a
Hillside
the
Hospital.
result,
the Journal of
(see
IIIb).
various
drugs
therapies
evaluating
project
.A

Concomitantly, our interest has continued in the biochemistry of
convulsive therapy. we have observed that diethazine, a potent anticholinergic
demonstrated
has
a
Further
analysis
electroshock
effect.
the
drug, reverses
These
observadiethazine.
LSDHZS
to
and
mescaline
between
marked similarity
as
system
cholinesterase-acetylcholine
the
of
confirm
the
significance
tions
which
behavior
of
psychotic
the
type
a basic mechanism for psychotic behavior may be affected by convulsive therapy.

Percgption:

(D)

have
change
behavioral
of
index
an
as
studies of perceptual tests
continued. We have defined the relationship between the degree of perceptual
demonstrated
Our
have
studies
function.
alteration and the degree of altered brain
Our

but
the
response,
in
perceptual
only
not
type
of
personality
the significance
also in the physiologic response, to convulsive therapy.
Our studies of tactile perception clarified the role of strength of
stimulus and of the type of instructions (set) in the reported reponses.

Individual Differences in Behavioral Responses:
The program of study of the ways in which individual differences in
various
to
of
subjects
and
affect
response
physiology
the
perception, personality
of
neurophysiologic
Green's
Dr.
studies
under
well
way.
is
psychiatric therapies
Dr.
emphasis
and
Pollack's
EEG
electroshock,
to
the
response
differences affecting
of
the
both
phase
in
are
drug
to
therapies
on perceptual aspects as they relate
collecting data in consecutive groups of subjects.
(E)

III.
(A)

New

Pro ects - Pro am.l 8

Inhalant Convulsive Therapz:

In the studies of electroshock, we have been puzzled by the significance
of the electric current in the treatment response. In the convulsive-subconvulsive
was
aftreatment
the
for
response
seizure
the
of
the
control study,
significance
compound,
inhalant
an
Recently,
clear.
not
was
current
of
the
role
but
firmed,
conﬂescribed
simple
was
as
a
safe,
of
ether
anesthesia,
the
to
ethyl
similar
vulsant. We visited the laboratory at Spring Grove State Hospital, Maryland, We
and observed the treatment. It was reliable, quick and easy for the patient.
have obtained a supply of this compound and are undertaking a study on February
of
biochemical
and
effects
psychologic
of
neurophysiologic,
the
clinical,
lst,
convulsive therapy using this compound.
(B)

Mbde

of Action of Psychophammaoologic agents:

experiences with other forms of therapy have led us to formulate a
the
In
agents.
essence,
psychopharmacologic
(see
IIc)
regarding
hypothesis
and
kind
of
effect
the
degree
to
related
behavior
which
is
affect
drugs
to
degree
EEG.
Fbr
this
the
purpose,we
by
measurable
in
part,
brain
have
on
function,
they
and
personnel
equipment
for
special
obtained
and
support
have written a protocol
from.the U.S.P.H.S. and various pharmaceutical concerns.
Our

�-l+-

In these studies, patients referred for drug therapies, as chlorpromazine,
promazine, reserpine, meprobamate, etc. , undergo special tests before and during
treatment, which may predict and reflect the treatment response.
(0) Psychologic and Sociologic Factors in Out Patient Therapy;

result of our studies in inpatients defining certain psychologic
sociologic factors as they affect treatment choice and treatment response,
As a

and
we have made predictions regarding the outpatient population.
to undertake a sociologic study of outpatients, and extend our

studies this Spring.
IV.
(A)

W318

We

are planning

inpatient

AND. I’UBLICATIONS:

Eigerimental Psychiatry Issue, Journal of Hillside Hospital:

of this Department wrote five
articles reflecting various aspects of our study program for the October 1957
issue of the Journal. This encompassed the whole issue. Such an effort is
unique in the Journal‘s history.
At Dr. Tarachow's

(B)

invitation,

members

Publications:

In addition to these five articles, our report on the relation between
EEG changes and treatment response in electroshock appeared in the Archives of
Neurology and Psychiatry. Seven other reports have been accepted for publi cation and two others are in the hands of editors as of January let.
(G)

Presentations:

Reports of our studies have been presented to psyc iatric, neurologic
and psychologic societies. Twelve reports were made before National societies
in the U.S. and three before International Congresses in Brussels and Zurich
during the summer. These reports have been generally well received.
V.

PERSONNEL:

changes in personnel have been made. We have requested, and the Research
Committee and Medical Director have approved, a restatement of the titles for
staff members from "Research Assistant" and "Senior Research Assistant" to
"Research Associate". The present staff consists of nine members including:
No

Martin A. Green, M. D.
Joseph Jaffe, M. D.
Robert L. Kahn, Ph.D.
Hyman Korin, Ph.D.
Max

Pollack, Ph.D.

Associate (Neurophysiology)
- Research
"
"
(Psychiatry)
-"
"
"
(Experimental Psychology;
"
"
(Experimental Psychology
"
"
(Ehcperimental Psychology)
-

and four technical assistants: Mrs. Hannah Mosque'ra (EEG) , Mrs. Jean Kolodw
and Mrs. Ann Horowitz(~?sycholinguistics) and Mrs. Janet Bowie (Secretary).

�-5VI.
(A)

TENTﬁIIVE BUDGEE PROJECTION:

1228-52.

Personnel:

In addition to the personnel listed above, we will request the addition
of a Research.Associate in Social Psychology; and a redesignation of the halftime neurophysiologist to a full-time status. These items will increase the
budget by $9500 above authorized annual increments for ongoing personnel.
(B)

Supplies.

Em

ment and Travel:

There will be an increase of $l000 in supplies and travel and a specific
equipment expense of $5200 for an EEG Analyzer. This instrument will provide
greater flexibility in EEG analysis. A supplementary request for this amount
has been asked of the U.S.P.H.S.
L

Total Egpensesz

(C)

av"

.

total

expenses for 1958-59
1957-58, an increase of $16,98h.
The

(D)

will be $95,796. as against $78,812

k"

"u.

Income:

In the past six months, this Department has been more successful than
anticipated in attracting research funds from private and governmental sources.
Fbr the current year, we anticipated $33,595 and so far have been advised that
we can expect $h3,h31 for 1957-58, an increase of $9,836 over expectations.
Fbr 1958-59; we have already been assured of $50,66h which is $7,233
more than 1957-58. It may be of interest that we already have funds for 1959-60
in the amount of $15,297. These grants totalling $115,235 have been made available to the Department for the period April 1, 1957 to December 1960.

Max

Mszb/b

Fink,

M. D.

A}\

fork¢3”4
We

Respectfully submitted,

V‘

�</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
          </elementContainer>
        </elementSet>
      </elementSetContainer>
    </file>
  </fileContainer>
  <collection collectionId="3">
    <elementSetContainer>
      <elementSet elementSetId="1">
        <name>Dublin Core</name>
        <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
        <elementContainer>
          <element elementId="50">
            <name>Title</name>
            <description>A name given to the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="3">
                <text>Research Files and Unpublished Works</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
        </elementContainer>
      </elementSet>
    </elementSetContainer>
  </collection>
  <elementSetContainer>
    <elementSet elementSetId="1">
      <name>Dublin Core</name>
      <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
      <elementContainer>
        <element elementId="50">
          <name>Title</name>
          <description>A name given to the resource</description>
          <elementTextContainer>
            <elementText elementTextId="67274">
              <text>Progress and annual reports; research activities (folder title).</text>
            </elementText>
          </elementTextContainer>
        </element>
        <element elementId="51">
          <name>Type</name>
          <description>The nature or genre of the resource</description>
          <elementTextContainer>
            <elementText elementTextId="67275">
              <text>Text</text>
            </elementText>
          </elementTextContainer>
        </element>
        <element elementId="43">
          <name>Identifier</name>
          <description>An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context</description>
          <elementTextContainer>
            <elementText elementTextId="67276">
              <text>mfp-03-01-001-0-005</text>
            </elementText>
          </elementTextContainer>
        </element>
        <element elementId="40">
          <name>Date</name>
          <description>A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource</description>
          <elementTextContainer>
            <elementText elementTextId="67277">
              <text>1957</text>
            </elementText>
          </elementTextContainer>
        </element>
        <element elementId="39">
          <name>Creator</name>
          <description>An entity primarily responsible for making the resource</description>
          <elementTextContainer>
            <elementText elementTextId="67278">
              <text>&lt;a title="Fink, Max, 1923-" href="http://id.loc.gov/authorities/names/n79039548" target="_blank"&gt;Fink, Max, 1923-&lt;/a&gt;</text>
            </elementText>
          </elementTextContainer>
        </element>
        <element elementId="49">
          <name>Subject</name>
          <description>The topic of the resource</description>
          <elementTextContainer>
            <elementText elementTextId="67279">
              <text>&lt;a href="http://id.loc.gov/authorities/subjects/sh85113021"&gt;Research Files&lt;/a&gt; and Unpublished Works -- Hillside Hospital, Glen Oaks, NY, 1953-1965</text>
            </elementText>
          </elementTextContainer>
        </element>
        <element elementId="46">
          <name>Relation</name>
          <description>A related resource</description>
          <elementTextContainer>
            <elementText elementTextId="67280">
              <text>The Max Fink Collection</text>
            </elementText>
          </elementTextContainer>
        </element>
        <element elementId="41">
          <name>Description</name>
          <description>An account of the resource</description>
          <elementTextContainer>
            <elementText elementTextId="67281">
              <text>Letters; Personality factors in behavioral response to electroshock therapy (draft) by Robert L. Kahn and Max Fink;  Progress reports of departmental activities; A proposed study for the behavioral assay of new drugs by Fink; Report of activities</text>
            </elementText>
          </elementTextContainer>
        </element>
        <element elementId="47">
          <name>Rights</name>
          <description>Information about rights held in and over the resource</description>
          <elementTextContainer>
            <elementText elementTextId="67282">
              <text>&lt;a title="IN COPYRIGHT - EDUCATIONAL USE PERMITTED" href="http://rightsstatements.org/vocab/InC-EDU/1.0/" target="_blank"&gt;IN COPYRIGHT - EDUCATIONAL USE PERMITTED&lt;/a&gt;</text>
            </elementText>
          </elementTextContainer>
        </element>
        <element elementId="48">
          <name>Source</name>
          <description>A related resource from which the described resource is derived</description>
          <elementTextContainer>
            <elementText elementTextId="67283">
              <text>Special Collections and University Archives, University Libraries. Stony Brook University Libraries (State University of New York).</text>
            </elementText>
          </elementTextContainer>
        </element>
        <element elementId="44">
          <name>Language</name>
          <description>A language of the resource</description>
          <elementTextContainer>
            <elementText elementTextId="80930">
              <text>en-US</text>
            </elementText>
          </elementTextContainer>
        </element>
        <element elementId="42">
          <name>Format</name>
          <description>The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource</description>
          <elementTextContainer>
            <elementText elementTextId="87491">
              <text>application/pdf</text>
            </elementText>
          </elementTextContainer>
        </element>
        <element elementId="45">
          <name>Publisher</name>
          <description>An entity responsible for making the resource available</description>
          <elementTextContainer>
            <elementText elementTextId="94052">
              <text/>
            </elementText>
          </elementTextContainer>
        </element>
        <element elementId="37">
          <name>Contributor</name>
          <description>An entity responsible for making contributions to the resource</description>
          <elementTextContainer>
            <elementText elementTextId="100613">
              <text/>
            </elementText>
          </elementTextContainer>
        </element>
      </elementContainer>
    </elementSet>
  </elementSetContainer>
  <tagContainer>
    <tag tagId="3">
      <name>Research</name>
    </tag>
  </tagContainer>
</item>
