http://exhibits.library.stonybrook.edu/mfp/files/original/64a99dded912958ccb069721b48d1a94.pdf cd50f4f0066e00abefa580f375e4163d PDF Text Text < n w w Y,._..—»-v...r-—"4~wn‘ . 7 ..... 2 “m w— W... ,m. «wrwvvmew—F ................................Y1kildliq33&u3 3330nqqfi efiz 30 ahrsbntjs as? ion at jroqox std? :notouisqgg 03 qu goljeovejnk aid: amines: Try—r‘. -~.——»——.-—w—w——,>.——_. has 332 .lsnzuot 30 valnujroqqc ed: 103 uov 333 inng June 23, 1969 .zboje anilq Dr. Peter Kallaway Baylor College of Medicine Houston, Texas Dear Peter,.31unv vtexsonkl I have read and re~rssd the article. "EEG and Hypnotic Susceptibility"; and when my recommendations appeared imprecise, I shared the report with my associates. Our conclusions are mixed, although the recommendation is specific. .W.V flirt? ts” v133errmmect is a good one, and the problem important. desire to relate a behavioral variable (hypnotic suggestihility) with a quantified set of EEG variables is coeesndabls. hath measures. that of behavior and EEQ are well selected, and seeaingly are the most efficient available. \lv The Negative: The attempt to relate an attitudinal variable with EEG measures collected at disparate points in time has been unenccessful in most studies; and when a relationship is reported, it is usually not sustained in later studies. The best relationships are those measured in close temporal relations-- the closer the better. so of that errors 64 spa due The sampling rate is low: the filtering inadequate, to aliasing are highly probable. (A sampling rate leads to folding of 60 cps in 3-5cps). The Grass 3 dB contribute to this difficulty and especially if the authors are not aware that many Grass instruments bypass the filters for the tape outputs. This should be enquired into in their system. filters Sample sizes are very small, and the use of means spurious. What variability measures were used? Were split samples (#5 vs £5. or 30vs30v930) assessed to insure that the variability of these very small samples was not excessive ? may be Five significant measures of 96 (at a minimum) or of 600 (at a maximum) are not impressive. Especially if they are derived statistically and not from any theoretic point of view. The absence of a priori hypotheses degrades studies, and I regret the authors did not choose to make their ideas clear and test them. The statistical approach to science is very unsat~ isfactory. «Wm-r .— �QMG ‘\~. WMWt1¢samttbintyo3uoco39.303.3333333933313393... 6033133133: 11113 Journsl. EEG 'Ihuk you fat - stat: 311°: report than 239: .33 sent 13, no: 39 to opportunity of 2 m “Mud. of .0... the mm; this Inna-cm 13u3I133 33331 .36 3a131b3fl 10 aaaIIoa 301138 . 33:3? .1333on ’ 113333111 35313. .3333? 333a a13aaq1fi has 333" .3I31333 333 b333—33 has has: 3133 I .331333331 b33lsqq3 Inol3nbanunaoo3 1: 3331 533;”13111313q933u3. I dauodsIa 1331a 933 IaatguIanna xufi .1333130333 13 3313 330333 9d: 533333 .91113933 :1 antaabuamnoae3 353 HI: 1131, 3.9.. .113: ad: baog 3 at has Janna-:1 331qu (13111313331333 313031131 3I331331 1330113333 3 333133 03 33133b 3d? .33333333 333! .nfilhhnuuuos 31 33I331331 as: In 333 haIIIJnIsp 3 3311 333 333 11331333: has.13333I33- II3vva3a can has Iotvidad in 3333 3a3191§13 ' soanmutry ' _ 4 If! ~ 1 .aIth1313 3308 3I331331 I3315331333 a3 333I33 03 3133333 ad! :3113139H Inasd 33‘ 3313 31 333191 333331315 33 baaaaIIoa 33333333 933 H313 53330333 31 3133301311333 #333 has 53315333 3303 31 Luis-oaoucau 3113380133I3: 3333 331.331hu33 33331 31 533133303 303 1Iqunu 31 31 .333334 333 3333Ia 3d3 -333133I33 I33oqut3 33013 31 53393333 33033 333 V .33snp3h331 331333I11 333 :uoI 31 3333 anIanaa ed? 3333 331Iqann A) .31333331‘113313 333 33133113 03 sub 330333 3nd: on 3333111 81 E 33339 3d? .(3133-C at 333 08 Io gnIbIoi e3 IhaoI 313 AB 10 333 3303333 333 11 1113133139 but 13I3311311 3133 03 3333133303 ad: 30! 3393111 933 333113 33333333331 3333a 1333 3333 33313 333 96 113033 31d? .33nq3uo 3333 .333313 31333 31 0331 b33knpnn 3333- In 333 333 but .1133! 1331 333 33313 311332 saiqitu 31133 333w thnne 333' 31333313 131I143133v 3.33 .3u013uq3 36 133 so 13111311331 333 3333 333331 33 53933333 (62310£310£ 33 .25 31 :1) I 311333333 303 33' 3313333 1331 33333 I II... 30 33) 32 19 33393333 33331113313 3111 333 1333 31 1II313313! .avtual3q31 309 333 (an-1:33 3 33) 003 30 .3311 lo 3310q 313330333 133 3031 303 ha. 1II3313313333 bav13nb (-3.131: 3 asbsxaob 3-33d3011d 130131 3 10 3333363 3d? 333b1 313d! 3133 33 330033 303 515 330fl3na 3d: 333333 I has .3015033 ~3snau 1331 31 3333133 03 danotqqs 13313313333 sdT .3333 3333 has xsoIo .130333131 � Dublin Core The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/. Title A name given to the resource Correspondence Text A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text. Dublin Core The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/. Title A name given to the resource Correspondence to: Kellaway, Peter Type The nature or genre of the resource Text Identifier An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context mfp-05-00-023-3-239 Date A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource 1969 Creator An entity primarily responsible for making the resource <a title="Fink, Max, 1923-" href="http://id.loc.gov/authorities/names/n79039548" target="_blank">Fink, Max, 1923-</a> Subject The topic of the resource Correspondence -- Correspondence Relation A related resource The Max Fink Collection Description An account of the resource Rights Information about rights held in and over the resource <a title="IN COPYRIGHT - EDUCATIONAL USE PERMITTED" href="http://rightsstatements.org/vocab/InC-EDU/1.0/" target="_blank">IN COPYRIGHT - EDUCATIONAL USE PERMITTED</a> Source A related resource from which the described resource is derived Special Collections and University Archives, University Libraries. Stony Brook University Libraries (State University of New York). Language A language of the resource en-US Format The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource application/pdf Publisher An entity responsible for making the resource available Contributor An entity responsible for making contributions to the resource Correspondence